Monday, June 29, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "Desperation Day"

Desperation Day (6x16)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Tami Sagher

One Paragraph Synopsis: Barney gets psyched up for Desperation Day, in which unattached women are likely to hook up out of a need to fill a void during Valentine's Day. He even goes as far as to spend the night with a few of Robin's coworkers, who head to McLarens that night, where he meets Nora. He falls for her, using his usual shtick, but she won't buy it. For what it's worth, they end up playing laser tag the next night, thanks to Robin. Lily, on the other hand, misses Marshall this Valentine's Day, as he's still in Minnesota. She heads over to be with him, expecting Marshall to take care of Judy, but it's Marshall that is being babied. And Ted, when he also heads to Minnesota to avoid furthering his relationship with Zoey.

Three good plots for a damn good episode. It makes me want to watch Predator, which I haven't done in a while, so off I go!

Or wait, I should say a little more. Marshall's story continues from the past couple of episodes, as he's still yet to leave Minnesota and is still around his family. On the surface, this is nice as Judy is always a welcome presence, but it's apparent that Marshall is still taking his time getting over his father's death.

Reverting to his childhood is one way to cope, but it's not exactly fair for anyone. Not to Judy, who has to play the role of his mother ala his youth, which she's too old to still pull off, and he's too old for it to seem reasonable. It's not fair to Lily, who misses her husband, and wants him home. It's not fair to GNB, who are missing one of their top lawyers. And it's not fair to Marshall, who needs to go back to New York and live his life.

Ted's trip to Minnesota is him similarly trying to avoid responsibilities. You can't screw up a relationship if you're playing Super Mario Kart with your best friend in Minnesota, right? (Also, that is totally an NES that they're using) His current problem is fearing that he's rushing into things, when the two want to go slow, especially since Zoey is still going through her divorce.

Maybe the slowness is unnecessary, though. Zoey and Ted express mutual interest, but it seems like they're the ones stopping themselves. Ted is hitting the brakes a little too hard, while Zoey seems to have too many second thoughts herself. Although to be fair, I would call things off if someone came over with a sleeping bag, myself. Thankfully, the episode shows a compromise, which is something that they both need.

Barney's plot is pretty cute, itself. We haven't seen him this smitten since he first fell for Robin, which must make Nora special. And Nazanin Boniadi (in a fake, but believable accent) is quite charming as Nora, making her a smart, reasonable woman that on the surface should be the exact opposite of Barney's type, but personal experience indicates that this couldn't further be from the truth. After all, Barney fell for Robin, didn't he?

Robin's pretty good at being a chill ex, which I usually note based on her interactions with Ted. But this time, she helps Barney out, which should indicate that she's over him. And maybe it does, but we're not done here yet, so we don't know if Nora will stay or not.

This episode is strong in regards to how it treats the characters. Lily might be the furthest off, since her pillow Marshall jokes are a little creepy. But even she is given some respectable moments otherwise as she's shown to be tired of Marshall's hiding. It comes together for a well-made episode that continues season 6's winning streak.

Sunday, June 28, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "Oh Honey"

Oh Honey (6x15)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Carter Bays & Craig Thomas

One Paragraph Synopsis: Zoey unwittingly hooks Ted up on a date with her hot cousin, remembered to the gang as Honey (Katy Perry). As hot and unwitting as she is, Ted isn't really interest, though. He wants Zoey. The thing is, she wants him too, and she has been divorcing the Captain in secret. Marshall, still in Minnesota, discovers all of this while talking to the other members of the gang, and helps them fill in the pieces themselves.

Well, it happened.

I've had my reservations about Ted and Zoey dating, but each time I watch this episode, I come out fairly happy. For one, it's built up well here. I'll get into the episode's framing device later, but it's especially nice to see how both of their sides are represented, even without going to either character's point of view. Yet by the end, it's easy to feel that both Ted and Zoey have their genuine reasons for liking each other, and that it's time for them to embrace it.

And the show also does well by bringing up their main obstacle, beyond even Zoey's marriage- their stance on the Arcadian. Or at least, they acknowledge it by bringing up how both of them are still dead set in their goals, but nothing can possibly change their current attraction to each other. This plot isn't too much of a focus in the episode, but is still present when Ted mentions his progress, and when Zoey is shown at a protest when Barney heads to work. It's a smart way to remind us of their conflict without forcing it down our throat.

They still need to figure things out if this is going to work. Because while the episode makes me feel happy, I'm still skeptical. Their relationship can work for now, but how long will it take for their opposing points to come back into fruition? Ted still has work to do on the Arcadian, and Zoey still hasn't bended her position. Maybe this time together will help them find a compromise.

Thankfully, this all works thanks to the episode's call waiting framing device. We don't leave the Eriksen household as he's told the whole story through phone, and everybody gives him a unique twist on the story. Including Zoey and Ted, who listen as Marshall helps fill the episode out at the end.

Robin tells what seems to be the fullest truth, as she doesn't have much of a horse in this race. She has no real attraction to Ted anymore, and just wants him happy, which Zoey just might do. Although she does lie to Zoey about Marshall hating her, but that's okay. Ted's a son of a bitch.

Which Lily understands, as she doesn't get too much to do herself besides nailing the best line of the episode. Which she shares with Marshall, but I digress.

And Barney continues to live the lie, since it's far more interesting than the truth. So he says, but it's fun to hear his fabrication. It's cute to see that he even feels the need to lie to such great lengths to Marshall, who doesn't care about his conquests at all, but it is Barney, after all. And we the audience do get to see him break down to Honey, which is another great moment.

Honey helps fill in the rest to Marshall, which is another fun moment for her. I'm not much of a fan of Katy Perry's music, but she has decent acting chops here, playing the naive character pretty well. It isn't exactly a dignified role, but it is a sitcom, after all, and the character works well for laughs. Even if some of her stupidity seems exaggerated, but this is still coming from Ted, after all.

The moments in Minnesota help to keep us in real time, even if they aren't the most exciting aspect. But seeing Judy is always a treat, and this is the most that we've seen of one of Marshall's brothers in a while. Together, they fill in the pieces for a fun, promising episode. Even if we don't see how the show will live up to its promise. Or if.

Wednesday, June 24, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "Last Words"

Last Words (6x14)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Carter Bays & Craig Thomas

One Paragraph Synopsis: Back in Minnesota, Marshall is getting ready for Marvin's funeral, and the gang is doing their best to make things easier for him. Ted and Barney are looking up funny videos to crack him up a little; Lily is aiming her sights towards Judy, who needs a break from all the stress; and Robin is like the service's own Mary Poppins, with a purse full of everything you can imagine. But nothing they can do will really help Marshall out, who feels that he was robbed of meaningful last words with his father, after hearing what Marvin's last conversations were like to Judy and his brothers. All it takes is a newly found voicemail to change his perspective, though.

This shouldn't have worked. The Korean-themed string of gags and the joke about Barney getting Marshall's fifteen-year-old cousin should have hurt this episode a little more (but hey, Barney did instantly give back her number, so at least he isn't THAT gross).

But even problematic material can't hold back what is a fantastic episode, as we get to say goodbye to Marvin with Marshall and his loved ones, and say hello to a new, exciting chapter in the gang's life. "Last Words" has been compared to "Chuckles Bites the Dust" and the first Hartman-less NewsRadio episode, perhaps haphazardly, but in a well-meaning way, as this succeeds at what it aims for.

Marshall brings up a good point- how would you feel if the most recent conversation you had with your father was your last? Mine was about a decade ago, and I don't really remember it, so I'm not a good person to come to here. But this paints a picture for the gang, who each considers where they stand with their father.

We haven't seen Alfred since his first appearance in the second season, as he and Virginia told Ted of their divorce. Since then, it's become apparent that he's grown into an awkward 60-something-year-old attempting to be one of the cool kids. While Ted rightly isn't attracted to this side of Alfred, the fact remains that this is his father, and he wishes for a better relationship with him, but first he should be in a better place.

Mickey has never been great with Lily, and it seems that in the year since "Slapsgiving 2", he's been incarcerated. Lily's inability to even answer or respond to him shows where her current place with her father is, but at the same time, it seems as if Mickey hasn't done any growing himself. It doesn't seem like he's still in jail anymore, if Lily can easily contact him, which means that they have the chance to work on their bond together.

Robin still feels inadequate to her father, which is something he reciprocates (this episode also introduces Ray Wise as Robin Sr, as Eric Braeden chose to not reprise the role. Wise will play Robin Sr. from here on at). Robin just wants her father to appreciate her a little, and it doesn't seem like she's at fault here, even if she is too willing to open up to her.

Barney, meanwhile, hasn't seen his father in about 30 years, and even then only knew him as "Uncle" Jerry. This is why he stayed absent when the other characters talked about their father, as much as it must hurt. His call to Loretta at the end of the episode indicates that this should change soon, though.

Marshall, on the other hand, had a generally great relationship with his father. They loved each other dearly, and kept in contact regularly, even getting a chance to see each other days before Marvin died. But all Marshall can muster his father's last words to him being were "rent Crocodile Dundee 3!" When his family gets to their stories during the service, it makes sense that Marshall feels left out.

This voice mail shouldn't mean too much, but to Marshall, it's everything. It's a chance to hear his father's voice one last time, and it could mean something very poignant. Yet his initial pause makes it seem like Marshall isn't ready to accept the possibilities, though. What if Marvin just asked about his foot cream? Or what if he just accidentally butt dialed Marshall?

It turns out that this was a butt dial, which hurts Marshall at first, even going as far as to call out to God. One thing the series only occasionally, and unobtrusively acknowledges, is Marshall's faith. Coming from a small town, it makes sense that Marshall is at least somewhat religious, but the show knows better than to throw it at our face, unlike other series. Instead, we usually see Marshall's faith in little comedic bits, like his belief in the supernatural.

But there's no denying that Marshall has a lot of faith and belief in his heart, enough of it goes to a higher being. Here, he's legitimately angry towards his God, feeling that he was denied a chance to hear his father's voice again. Still, Marshall never doubts his God's existence, and thus is rewarded with a real, touching message from Marvin. Along with something about his foot cream, but that doesn't matter. A great choice in camera angle, on top of Segel's acting chops and smart pacing keep this as one of the show's most poignant moments. And this comes from someone with no faith.

Yet Marshall decides to not share the story of the last voicemail, and instead tells the Crocodile Dundee 3 story. Sometimes, the original take is the best in terms of storytelling purposes, as it works like gangbusters during his piece.

This is a great way to round up the episode's honest depiction of grief. None of it is left on the others, who are each given memorable ways to keep Marshall and Judy's spirits alive, but this is Marshall's episode, as Segel knocks it right out of the park. This is the show at its best.

Tuesday, June 23, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "Bad News"

Bad News (6x13)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Jennifer Hendricks

One Paragraph Synopsis: There's a countdown to big news, and it starts when Lily and Marshall fear that they might not be able to conceive children. They're recommended a doctor who focuses on fertility, Dr. John Stangel, who looks a lot like Barney- more than the doppelganger Lily thought she saw at the end of last season, anyway. His tests prove that Lily is just fine, which makes Marshall have his doubts. It becomes increasingly harder for him to "test" his fertility out when his parents come to visit, too. Dr. Stangel confirms that Marshall is quite fertile himself, which means that he and Lily are more than ready to have kids. Just as he's about to tell Lily the good news, though, he's hit with some bad news to counterbalance- his father died shortly after returning home to Minnesota.

Keep in mind that it's been mentioned by future Ted more than once that Marshall and Lily will have a child. Or children. Recall that he said "first child" in "Last Cigarette Ever", after all.

That should have made the idea of the bad news being that one of them is infertile be moot, and it is. In fact, the episode makes it seem that the title is purposefully misleading- that what is expected to be bad news doesn't occur, and the two get to have children after all. And that would have been fine. Welcome, even.

But the show has been wise about its use of Marvin this season, giving him more screentime than he's had in years, as Bays, Thomas and crew remind us of the bond he and Marshall shares. Of the character's parents shown thus far, Marvin and Judy have the most material to go back on, just as Marshall has the strongest history to dig into. This is able to work because of the working bond that gets the characters together.

And it makes the reveal hurt. Not as much as it must hurt for Marshall, but the reveal is well done. Especially since the idea of a fake out was given to Segel and Hannigan, who were expecting Lily to be pregnant by episode's end. The reveal of Marvin's death was a last-minute addition (not for the episode, but this was something purposefully kept from the actors), which they share with great sadness and realness to their performance.

The countdown is a great stealth addition, helping the audience to anticipate news, whether good or bad. I'm not sure how many first-time viewers catch the numbers, as some of them are placed in a nice, subtle manner, but others are easy enough to catch to show some kind of pattern. It's something the show won't really try again, but as a weird concept, it fits here.

Robin's story is pretty good, herself. The return of Sandy Rivers was welcome, even if only to see Alexis Denisoff mockingly mug for the camera again. But it allows for Robin to get closer to her dreams, even though she has to deal with corporate hazing first. The result is a fun highlight reel of some of her most awkward moments that remains entertaining as reminders to where she's from.

But this is only a taste of the course coming in the next episode. A big episode that aims high and reaches for most of its goals, Marshall still has yet to say goodbye to Marvin. Let's go.

How I Met Your Mother Review- "The Mermaid Theory"/"False Positive"

The Mermaid Theory (6x11)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Robia Rashid

One Paragraph Synopsis: Now that she's been spending time with the gang, Zoey and Ted have been bonding a little, to the point that they start having one-on-one time. Lily warns Ted of the implications, with Zoey being a married woman, as Ted agrees and tries to not make their friendship too close. The Captain, on the other hand, seems oblivious to any implication, as he becomes closer to the gang despite having a creepy appearance. Ted is avoiding Zoey becoming a mermaid, and trying to keep her as a manatee, a piece of advice that Barney has installed onto him and Marshall, who in turn tries to keep Robin at a distance in fear of her becoming a mermaid. A night out with the two almost ruins this, as Barney and Lily fight about the theory, or at least will at a later time, as Ted gets his stories crossed.

False Positive (6x12)


Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Craig Gerard & Matthew Zinman

One Paragraph Synopsis: Marshall and Lily are told that they are expecting, news that excites not only them, but the gang. It helps Robin push herself forward to get a research job at the Worldwide News Network, instead of settling to flip coins for Million Dollar Heads or Tails, hosted by Alex Trebek. Barney also decides to do good, using part of his massive Christmas bonus to give his friends, and others, some of his favorite things, and even deciding to use the rest of it to donate to Sam Gibbs' church. All it takes is a false positive to change their minds, though- Robin decides to skip the "boring" job to become a "coin flip bimbo", while Barney spends most of what he planned to donate on a diamond-crusted suit. Even Lily and Marshall decide to have a dog instead of focusing on having a kid. But Ted, who is also helping Punchy out with his wedding, won't allow any of this.

One of HIMYM's greatest strengths is how it plays with its structure. The show uses a frequently fast pace and relies heavily on cutting back to the past, or occasionally even the future, to help tell unique stories while keeping fresh sitcom writing.

The concept of Ted failing to tell his story as originally portrayed is a great one, even if it only makes for the second or third-most important story in the episode. But it's backed by hilarious circumstances based on his ability to get the facts right, even down to a magic trick of Barney's that seems great, but is actually pretty cruel.

This ends up being even more funny, since Lily and Barney's events do really happen later in the series. Complete with Ted showing up in a green dress. But this plays with the show's concept of time and structure, something it plays with well and often.

It is about time that Ted gets a anecdote so completely wrong, as he's telling his children these a good 20 years into the future, and he only rarely gets fuzz on some details. The joke might have been even better if this was more pertinent to the story at hand, but Barney's Mermaid Theory lessen to Lily is very minor, all things considered. That's why it isn't hard to believe that Ted can't get the story straight.

"False Positive" is more basic for the show- it takes us into the mind of each of the characters after discovering Lily's pregnancy, and comes back when this is proven to be false. But framing an episode on each character is something the series does well, as this is true here.

Both episodes succeed from giving each of the main characters a fairly equal amount of attention, even despite some faults of their own. "False Positive" might be a little more meager in comparison, but to my eyes, it hurts the episode a little more- Coin Flip Bimbo. Seriously?

My problem with "The Mermaid Theory" comes from what might be the main plot, though. I don't really buy, or care about, Ted and Zoey's relationship. At least not right now. The episode does gloss over their conflicting views, to the benefit (or perhaps detriment?) of its sake, but it's hard to forget how Ted and Zoey met.

Ted and Zoey can become friends, and maybe even find mutual ground. But so far, there hasn't been an attempt on either end for them to come to some sort of agreement on the Arcadian. Both of them have fair points- it's a (fictional) landmark! That's shown its age and is increasingly becoming beyond repair- but also keep in mind how Ted ditched his initial plans to keep the facade of the Arcadian after discovering that Zoey is married. And hasn't brought it or any other idea up since.

I hope that if the show continues in the direction of Ted and Zoey dating, that it's smart enough about their issues to make it work while still sticking to their characters. Ted isn't Dr. X anymore, while a big part of why the Captain, and ever-so-slightly Ted, are attracted to Zoey is her crackerjack personality. Remove her edges, and she's not the same.

Ted sings a different tune in the following episode, though. In "False Positive", he seems to be the one who is happy with his place for a change. This is probably because Ted does the most to ensure that he changes, while Robin and Barney have been happy being dormant for a while, just as Lily and Marshall have done so much together that they are able to focus their attention on growth towards conceiving their future child.

And it's in this moment of clarity where gets to shine. Ted proves that he can be a good best man and side planner to Punchy, who needs all the encouragement he can get; shows that he understands Robin well enough that he won't allow her to waste her future on a half-ass game show, and pushes for her to take  job in the CNN composite; refuses to stand for Barney's bullshit too much longer, at least in terms of how he spends his money; and won't let Marshall and Lily coast on what they want most, ie a child. And he gets a great moment at the end where he makes sure all of his friends do good and live up to their potential.

Before I go, I'll also give props to Robin and Marshall's story in "The Mermaid Theory". Their friendship pairing isn't the most important element of the show, but is always welcome when explored, since they're both well-meaning people that bond well. And also, if someone as hot as Robin puked on me, I'd probably consider them a manatee for life, too.

Sunday, June 21, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "Blitzgiving"

Blitzgiving (6x10)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Theresa Mulligan Rosenthal

One Paragraph Synopsis: The Blitz is a Wesleyan tradition, a fellow who leaves an event early and misses on something amazing, and is doomed to repeat this until someone else bails while they stay. For years, Ted and Marshall's friend Steve (Jorge Garcia) occupied the position of the Blitz, but when Ted leaves the bar early the night before Thanksgiving, he takes on the role. One thing he missed was seeing Zoey, who joined the gang, Steve included, and became their new bff, even offering them, Ted included, to have Thanksgiving with her while the Captain sees his daughter the next day. After discovering that the gang crashed his oven as a result of their partying, Ted ends up taking her offer, as they go to Zoey's for Thanksgiving. Things almost don't go well, but finding out Zoey's relationship with her daughter-in-law, he tries to reconcile.

THE GENTLEMAN!

This is a pretty simple episode, but a lot of fun to watch. But I stepped out for a minute, and apparently a string of cats came and deleted my review. But it's enjoyable, even for someone who could never get into Lost and only understand Garcia's references on a casual level. To be fair, he is game, and this helps to humanize Zoey a little more, who hasn't overstayed her welcome quite yet.

Hopefully by my next review, I won't be the blitz. Aww man.

Friday, June 19, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "Glitter"

Glitter (6x09)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Kourtney Kang

One Paragraph Synopsis: Barney has found the next piece of the Robin Sparkles puzzle, when he gets a tape of her old children's show. But he and the rest of the gang were not expecting how erotic the show was, nor were they privy to the existence of her old co-star/best friend Jessica Glitter (Nichole Scherzinger). When Robin gets agitated after being asked about her, the gang do some digging and determine that they drifted apart when Glitter became a mother, a thought that terrifies Lily, who is increasingly getting comfortable with baby talk. It takes some more clue work for her and Marshall to find Glitter, who informs her that the only reason she and Robin stopped being close is due to her own problems keeping up with friends after having a kid, which is something Lily can work on her.

It's funny, this is the third Sparkles episode, but the joke hasn't worn thin. By now, it's treading almost entirely on the familiarity of the show's iconic turn with "Slap Bet", a fact that Kang, who has written each of these episodes, isn't afraid to remind us of.

But that's a part of the charm here. Six seasons in, and there isn't too much new for us to discover about the characters, so it's fair and fun to come back to some of our favorite aspects of their lives that the show has touched on, such as Robin's teenage days as a TV/pop star.

"Glitter" isn't just old gags, though- there actually is emotional weight here, as the discovery of Robin's old BFF Jessica Glitter brings a conflict point that makes too much sense to not explore at some point, being her issues with babies. While Robin and Jessica's departing friendship doesn't explain her lack of interest in having children (not like it really needs much explanation- she doesn't want kids, end of story), it does give us an idea of why she is so particularly allergic to kids in general.

Robin has abandonment issues, more or less brought on by her father's negligent parenting, and has various ways of coping with them. We've first seen this after seeing her random trip to Argentina after her split with Ted, when she came home with Gael, unable to separate the difference between a summertime fling and her next serious relationship. Then there were her drunken calls to Don in "Architect of Destruction", a haphazard subplot that does further show her issues with acceptance.

And then her long-standing grudge with small children seems to be how she handled her loss of Jessica's friendship. While there does seem to be a lifelong ambivalence towards kids (even when she was a child and had to deal with her younger sister, after all!), much of these reactions can likely be traced to when Jessica had her child and quickly drifted apart. We don't get to see much of their friendship way back when, but it seems implied that they moved to New York together, which gives an idea of how close they are. It's also worth noting that the timeline between Jessica's pregnancy and the time this episode takes place fits with when Robin should have met the gang, which indicates that while she may have lost one close friend, she made four new ones, so it wasn't all for moot.

I think Robin is such a strong character, that I would be a lot more critical if this didn't turn out to give a good backing for her characters actions, and thankfully the episode delivers as an episode. And it's a great episode for her friendship with Lily, who herself has a tendency to indulge in her passions. Here, she seems to genuinely want Robin to share her enthusiasm for her future child, but for various reasons, Robin doesn't want to jump on board. This shouldn't hurt Lily as much as it does, since she knows Robin's general attitude towards kids, but the sting of rejection towards your passion always burns.

Lily has her own low-key abandonment issues, also set off by her father, so they bond with that. At least mentally. And shows some ignorance on her part to not bend to Robin's needs when the split occurs, which is something that she is blessed by having Marshall for. When Lily won't play ball, she has someone who is willing to prep her up to go to bat, and does so almost seamlessly. It makes for a nice ending, as Robin and Lily's relationship is one of the show's key elements, which is something that Fryman, Smulders, and Hannigan recognize and nail in their resolution.

As for the Sparkles material? Do you need me to tell you that it's great? It's hard to not nail the silly atmosphere of the world of Robin Sparkles, especially as Kang seems to understand it better than anyone. She seemed to have fun writing some terrible innuendos into the show's script, which are wonderfully delivered by tried, confused actors.

And Scherzinger is fine as Jessica Glitter, for the little time she gets. The former Pussycat Doll may not have been as much of a comedic powerhouse as some of the show's previous guest star gets, but she totally fits the kids show's aesthetic, as her present day material is offered well on her part. She may not necessarily be the episode's highlight, but she serves it well.

I didn't mention Ted and Punchy's material in the synopsis, since it's hardly a subplot due to its lack of time. This is hardly a wash of screentime though, even if Punchy's shtick does indeed wear thin. His appearance does a good job of reflecting where Ted currently is in life though, as despite Punchy's seemingly sad lifestyle, he's actually pretty happy- he likes his job, he likes Cleveland, and he's happily engaged.

Seeing his old best friend, a loon who still makes scrotum jokes and still brings up the time he dookied his pants by the lake, getting closer to being married than he is has got to hurt. But Ted is hardly wasting his life now. He has two jobs that he loves, lives in the greatest city in the world, and has four great friends he can always depend on (give or take Barney). I think this episode shows that Ted and Punchy are both pretty fine where they are right now, even if Ted doesn't realize it himself.

But this is Robin's episode, and hey, two beavers are better than one! While every joke doesn't totally land (Barney's reality competition rejection monologue is a bit that gets a little more tedious each time you watch it), this is still a hilarious, well-meaning episode that continues to solidify season 6 as a return to form. Now don't forget the robot, everybody!