Wednesday, June 17, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "Canning Randy"/"Natural History"

Canning Randy (6x07)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Chuck Tatham

One Paragraph Synopsis: The Zoey drama isn't other yet- one cross line at Ted gives her the incentive to register for her class. And despite his best efforts to win his class over, it doesn't take long for her to get them against him and on board with saving the Arcadian. Ted tries to take the advice Lily gives him to win them back, with one final, successful result- threatening to fail his students when they ditch class for a protest, they come back in great numbers. At the same time, Marshall has to deal with Randy, a total loser of an underling who keeps on screwing up their work. It gets to the point that Marshall has to fire Randy, and when he changes his mind, it's revealed that Randy planned to use his severance check to start a microbrewery going. Eventually Marshall decides to do Randy the big solid, and fires him again.

Natural History (6x08)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Carter Bays & Craig Thomas

One Paragraph Synopsis: The gang is invited to a gala event at the Natural History Museum, being ran by GNB, and Arthur's old friend, the Captain (Kyle MacLachlan). From there, the night resumes. Ted runs into Zoey and learns that she's married to the Captain, an arrangement she isn't super happy about. They end up finding a mutual agreement against all odds, even with the articles she gets posted about Ted in the paper. Barney and Robin play a game of mess with the museum, only to get caught, when some important news is shared to Barney. And Lily is struggling with the reality that Marshall is willing to stick around at GNB, and give up his dreams of being an environmental lawyer.

I wasn't really expecting to find as strong of a connection between these two episodes that I have, but it's there- these are episodes about maturing, embracing second chances, about listening. And it helps that they're both pretty strong episodes.

Although there's a clear winner here for sure- "Natural History" might just make my top 10, give or take my position on "Subway Wars" on the day you ask me. But it's funny, on instinct I should have a grudge towards the episode based on a piece that Bays and Thomas stated during its commentary track. They actually compared this to a Billy Wilder script!

As much as I admire Wilder (he's my second favorite filmmaker, behind only Hitchcock), the thing is, this doesn't really fit his aesthetic. And I don't even mean his more dramatic material, such as Sunset Boulevard or Ace in the Hole- even his comedies, such as Some Like It Hot, Sabrina, and One Two Three have an entirely different pacing and structure to the show as a whole, this episode included.

But then I think about some of Wilder's scripts before he got his big break as a director. His and Charles Brackett's screenplays for Ninotchka, Midnight, and Ball of Fire were among the sharpest of screwball comedy, adhering to many of the recognized rules of the genre, but with his sharp sense for dialogue and character allowing for unique takes on the form. Midnight, for instance, almost exists as a satire of the very kind of film it is, with a respectful amount of snark used but not enough to overshadow his skill for formulating movie magic. When Wilder adapted to directing, his first film, The Major and the Minor, was a part of the screwball form, but he jumped the game shortly after.

This isn't meant to be a film lecture, though, but my point is that there is very much an element of screwball to "Natural History", and the show's creators were able to bless the screenplay with the right amount of biting wit to nail it.

The composition between the three plots are done equally well and in tune to each other, like many of the show's best scripts. None of the core five are forgotten- even Robin gets a chance to let her hair down and have fun, which is helpful in between all of the obnoxious things going on in her life.

Like Becky. The character of Becky isn't going to be a major one, in this season or as a whole, but she serves her purpose well. Having given up a great job in hopes of staying with her then-boyfriend, it doesn't seem like life for Robin could get any worse for the moment, until she becomes completely upstaged by a toddler. Becky's innocence can be cute, but I'd be annoyed too if I was in Robin's position.

Which is what gives her the incentive to appear in an adult diaper commercial. The build-up to the reveal in "Canning Randy" sticks to the show's strength of character building as exposition, as everything that's going on in the moment is about to burst, thanks to Lily's smart choices of words. The rise and fall of her secret and its reveal is almost reminiscent of "Slap Bet", which is always a great comparison to be made.

Barney doesn't have as much to do in "Canning Randy", other than to enable Marshall to fire Randy, a move that seems justified. We met Randy back in season 3, as Barney (somewhat) successfully attempted to be his wingman, but here it's clear that no amount of help he can give Randy can make the guy good at his job. Which is why Barney is tired of watching over him, and lends the guy to Marshall. That's about it.

As opposed to "Natural History", where his and Robin's story not only allows for fun gags, but comes into a surprisingly satisfying reveal of his true father. While this might have seemed to be an inappropriately dramatic sequence considering some of their other material, it's around this time that the three plots collide to make for meatier results, and thanks to the timing and talent of the cast and crew, the reveal packs a real punch. I think it's great, as it helps push Barney a little forward as he can no longer use his mother's lies to hide the truth. He knows, and it's about time he does something about it.

Lily spends most of her time in "Canning Randy" as a mentor for Ted, giving him advice on how to treat his students. The point of this material tries to show how college students aren't too different from kindergartners, and hey, if turning the lights on and off and going "ooooo" is enough to calm a group of young adults down, maybe there really isn't. And while Lily can go a little too far in her investigations, here her nudging to Ted actually pays off.

In "Natural History", though, Lily has something a little bigger to face- the fear of getting old and losing your dreams. While her ambitions as an artist aren't referenced, the implication is there as she sees her husband admit that he's willing to stay at GNB, instead of work for the environment. Too many people give up on their dreams to wake up every morning in a business suit, and Lily didn't seem ready to embrace the fact that she'll be married to someone like that.

It's a facet of maturing that we like to forget in hopes of keeping some kind of spark alive, but many succumb to letting these go and settle. And as much as Lily and Marshall are on point as a couple, they're on a different wavelength right now. Lily seems ready to accept Marshall's willingness to accept his place at the end of the episode, but she doesn't seem all too happy about it.

The use of college-aged Marshall and present-day Marshall as museum exhibits is clever. The former gives Lily a chance to come to grips, at least momentarily, with their current place in life, while the latter lets us know that his story isn't done yet. Since Marshall only claims to be happy with working at GNB for financial reasons, not for anything else. He still seems pretty miserable all around in both episodes.

The Marshall of "Canning Randy" isn't happy with having to fire Randy at all, even though the guy is clearly a dead-end. The episode has a well-meaning, if forgettable, framing device by showing Barney attempt to get Marshall to say that "GNB cares" for their damage control video (clips from it almost give off a Better Off Ted vibe, which is never a bad thing), a phrase he can't in good will say.

Because they don't! Or at least, not when they shouldn't. And to be fair, it is Marshall who messes things up for Randy by hiring him back. But this is a way to bring us into the dichotomy of GNB, a corporate who can fire with no remorse, but will screw you over just as your dreams are right in front of you. Marshall still means well, which is why he fires Randy for good after a whip of his craft beer. Between this and future Ted's foreshadowing, it's clear that Marshall isn't fully a suit yet. And seeing how this turns out will be great.

But Ted. Alright. And boy, Zoey can be a pest, as evident in the former episode. But the latter is interesting, showing the two almost getting along, especially after meeting the Captain, brilliantly portrayed by MacLachlan, who rocks every syllable he gets. But this shows a potential mutual agreement between the two. Maybe?

Two great episodes, with the latter getting the best out of everyone and ranking as one of the best of the season thus far. And this is a pretty fine season thus far.

Monday, June 15, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "Architect of Destruction"/"Baby Talk"

Architect of Destruction (6x05)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Carter Bays & Craig Thomas

One Paragraph Synopsis: The new GNB building has found a new location- it shall replace the Arcadian, a classic (and fictional) hotel that was a landmark in its heyday, but is showing its age and has become a product of waste. Ted initially is fine with the decision, but he changes his mind the next day, when he meets a new girl- Zoey- who convinces him of its importance to remain. He finds a compromise shortly after Zoey discovers his role in the design, but after discovering that she's married, Ted nixes it so he can stick to the original plan. Also, Marshall's friend Max has a small penis, and Lily tells Robin everything about their sex life.

Baby Talk (6x06)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Joe Kelly

One Paragraph Synopsis: After meeting Stuart and Claudia's daughter, Lily and Marshall decide to come up with baby names. The thing is, though, Lily only comes up with girl names, while Marshall only has boy names. It gets to the point that Marshall takes advice from his father on how to give birth to a boy, while Lily looks up tips to have a girl, which they soon recognize, and try their best to settle things out, as they end up agreeing to not care about gender as much as they do. Meanwhile, Ted is dating Robin's co-anchor Becky, while Barney tries to hook up with someone while talking like a little boy.

Well, we've hit it. Here's Zoey.

Jennifer Morrison is now better known for Once Upon a Time, but she's pretty solid as Zoey, all things considered. Her timing and delivery fit the show, just as her chemistry with Radnor isn't awful. But be prepared for more of her...

This is fine for a one-off, though. She fits Ted's usual structure as a cute but determined woman, who is more than able to be a great obstacle for him, just as the conflict works. Here, his architecture dreams are getting closer to becoming a reality, but they're being shattered solely by a woman who has a history of causing riots for her beliefs. This is something Ted would normally be all for, but not in his face like this.

Or maybe the conflict turns him on? While he seems against Zoey by the end of the episode (I wouldn't want anything to do with someone who egged my house, after all), it's hinted that he's still thinking of her. We're not done with Zoey yet, but does that mean that they're going to hook up? Hmm.

That sexual tension is what keeps the episode interesting, as it is present throughout, even by the end. Ted sees someone who reminds him of his days as Dr. X in her, for better or worse, and Zoey has that for better or worse vibe to her. It's what keeps Ted interested, for obvious reasons.

Since he already sees the Arcadium as a relic. The building isn't a penis metaphor, even with the subplot still around, but rather a metaphor for change. The Ted of the first five seasons would be more likely to keep the building as is alive just to please a girl, just as he almost did. All it takes is a wedding ring for him to change his mindset, and actually grow a pair.

The other plot is similarly fun, as it sticks to an old sitcom format- battle of the sexes- in a respectfully modern way with no need for winners. Like many other arguments like this, there isn't a completely universal truth here- not every woman is as frank, while some men are more than willing to get candid. But in general, this speaks to the theory that men and women speak about as much as each other, just in different subjects. What that subject is should make all the difference, but note how men aren't afraid to discuss even the grossest facts, just without some of the more colorful details women are open to.

Marshall's surprise comes from how Lily and Robin discuss their anecdotes about their men, which shocks his small-town mind. And to be fair, I don't disagree about one thing- there are some little facts that I don't want to know about my friends. But it makes for a fun build-up that resolves well at the end.

If I have one fault with the episode, it's the frequent transmisogyny in the first act. Yikes, but the show hasn't always been great with trans people and pronouns, I'm afraid. You take what you can get.

Because hey, "Baby Talk" is a better episode, even after a good turnaround from "Architect of Destruction"!

The most important part has to be Robin's discussion with ed and Barney about her feeling of necessity with them- Ted never felt like Robin needed her, which bothered him. Barney, meanwhile, never felt that Robin needed her, which is why he was so happy with her- Robin is her own woman, which is awesome. She's a strong, wonderful person, who is exactly the kind of woman Barney doesn't aim for a one-night stand with, which is why he liked dating her. It's a great character moment for the two.

On top of that, the episode calls out the lolita culture without directly addressing it, and is only aiming for the creepier aspects. The best use of that is the ending tag, which shows how close to home dating a younger-minded woman can be. And yikes.

Great stuff, though.

Sunday, June 14, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "Subway Wars"

Subway Wars (6x04)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Chris Harris

One Paragraph Synopsis: While discussing Robin's credibility as a New Yorker, Marshall's old law school buddy informs him that Woody Allen is eating across from him at a steakhouse downtown. The rest of the gang isn't interested, but each have their own methods on how to get there faster- Ted by bus; Lily by subway; Marshall on foot; and Barney has his own fail-safe method. This results in the five of them racing to head to the restaurant first, as Robin does her best to justify her status as a New Yorker.

It's crazy to believe, as great and respected as Fryman is as a director, that this is her only Emmy nomination in the show's 9-year run. She brought one of the most unique show formats in recent memory to life, just as she helps maintain some of the most talented performers in comedy, and she only gets one nomination, and doesn't even win.

But if nothing else, this is a great showcase for her talents behind the camera. Some of Fryman's best work is presented throughout, as she keeps the action exciting for each of the characters, giving them all plenty of breathing room even when they shouldn't have any.

While Marshall's material seems relatively inconsequential by comparison, it shows Fryman's talents by its composition. Marshall is kept square in the middle throughout his power sprint, as he's shown taking control with a heavy heart and bright face throughout, keeping the best of the character alive. It's fun to see, as Segel is framed and played well, and the urgency that keeps this episode going is never lost.

And it's also good for his character, as Marshall needs the boost of confidence right now. He and Lily are still early in their baby-making days, so it's no surprise to see them not make any progress yet, but to someone with a family history of fertility as strong as his, this has got to hurt for Marshall. This big stretch of exercise shows how Marshall still has it, and informs him that not only is he not the problem, it doesn't really matter to begin with.

Since Lily herself has the same fears. While their relationship is a complete 50/50 affair, she fears that it's her genes affecting things, haphazardly as she does. It takes a well-staged moment in Ranjit's cab for the two to come to the conclusion that this shouldn't matter, at least for right now. And it's true- what makes Lily and Marshall's relationship so great is how they don't rush, they just share everything with a mutual respect and admiration for each other. This is what keeps them and the show alive, why they're so good together.

Lily's material during the chase is less spastic than Marshall's, since she sits in a subway for a lot of it. But seeing how well she understand conductor talk brings a nice little reminder to her character- she is one of the only characters to be a native New Yorker (Barney being the other), so she understands the feel of the city better than most. Lily can cheat the system better than them all, as she best proves by leaving Robin in a delayed sub. This is still kept energized throughout, thanks to sharp camera directions and Hannigan's winning performance.

Ted, meanwhile, is doing pretty fine. His biggest issue right now is discovering ratemyteacher.com (a playo n the real ratemyprofessor, which apparently does actually contain fake reviews of Ted), which contains 62 glowing reviews, with only a single mediocre one among them. Being Ted though, he hastily glosses over this one poor review as it drives him wild.

And that's what his bus trip consists of- Ted trying so hard to not be boring, that he drives his fellow busriders crazy. What is even more crazy is that most of his fun facts would probably really interest his other students that gave him good reviews, but here it rightfully pisses off everyone in the area. A sharp angle is kept in the bus, which makes it easy to keep up with the action and tune into Radnor playing Ted as lovably nerdy as ever.

Barney... is doing pretty fine. Too fine. But that's a part of this episode's glowing charm, right down to his botched heart attack episode, which gives him a taste of just desserts when his scheme doesn't turn out as planned. Still, Fryman and Neil Patrick Harris keep a good balance of staying intense and keeping Barney's cool alive, which makes for a winning pair.

And it comes handy when Barney is shown to be the one who helps push Robin forward in the end, helping to keep their mixed, yet altogether welcome, bond alive. And Robin really does need the push, given how her life is right now. Losing Don and gaining Becky has got to hurt.

If this episode is about anyone, this is Robin's quest to prove her status as a resident of the greatest city on earth, as this is a reminder of where she is right now. She loves her native Canada and must miss her family, but her place in life is meant to be in the big apple, which Robin needs to take charge of. The episode does everything it can to show how Robin has adapted to New York, which it succeeds in, right down to Maury Povich having fun with his multiple cameos.

And Pamela Fryman constantly succeeds in making Robin feel as big and important as she possibly can, which is why this episode totally succeeds. The five characters are given plenty to do in a clever set-up, with each being given as much love as the other thanks to the one-two punch of Fryman's great direction and Harris' script. The series never won too many Emmys, but it sure deserved some love, at least here.

Thursday, June 11, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "Unfinished"

Unfinished (6x03)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Jamie Rhonheimer

One Paragraph Synopsis: The GNB building that Ted initially designed, but was later dropped by the conglomerate, is being picked back up for construction. Despite Barney's wishes, though, Ted chooses to not come back to help work on it, as he's happy with his job as a professor. But Barney alwaysssss gets his yes, and it takes some soul-searching before Ted eventually comes around to take the task on. At the same time, Robin is seeing Don's new job in Chicago, which is driving her insane, to the point that she constantly calls him to let him know her feelings. Lily tries her best to intervene, but Robin keeps on going crazy until she eventually moves on and forgets his number herself.

Rhonheimer doesn't alwaysssss get her ep, but when she tries, she can make some fine scripts for the show. And here's one!

It shows where Ted is in his current place in life that he even needs to debate if he wants to work on the GNB building or not. It's been a dream to make a building like this for years now, and the moment his chance arrives, bam. Doubt!

But Ted does truly seem happy being a professor. It fits his need as a perfectionist, while giving him the tiniest taste of parenthood. It's a pretty good position, and it's funny to think that he almost turned the job down. So this fits not only the character, but his place in the series. He isn't ready to find the mother and have children yet, but it's certainly time for him to find something meaningful in life, beyond his friends.

At the same time, working on the creation of his building should help with this even more. The GNB tower might serve as a metaphor for the building of his family, something Ted has wanted for a long time, but has never ceased the chance to obtain before. The thing is, the opportunity is right there, but he's stalling. This might mean that he's not ready, but something seems to tell him otherwise.

Stalling has always been an element of Ted's character, since the beginning. He a;ways seems to ruin the right opportunities (like Victoria) or aim for the wrong ones (like Robin), rather than give his choices more thought than he does. But following him in the half decade since shows me that he's actually ready for the responsibility and joy, if he doesn't purposefully screw things up.

I don't think that Barney is thinking about this though. He just wants the building made, and knows that Ted can do a good job of it. There's still a bit of friendly appreciation in Barney's actions, but keep in mind his general motives- this is going to look good for him. Which is why he really fights.

Ted has seen Barney make the moves on women before, but being the one who he is making the moves on gives him a different perspective, as he sees how good Barney is at it. Barney knows to not reach too much, which he doesn't, and to leave only something slight to give Ted incentive to change his mind. And it works, down to a T. The crazy thing is, Ted recognizes and loves this, which makes it fun to watch.

This is fun to watch, but I'm not as crazy on the b-plot. Smulders is too good as Robin to not make everything she does come out well, but it doesn't seem right for the character to come off as a jealous ex-girlfriend. There's truth to her bitterness- Don was wrong to leave her to take the job that she wanted so bad- but she shouldn't be calling him as angrily as she is, no matter how drunk she becomes.

And it's the thing that really drags down this fun episode. This is old hat, and it doesn't work for the show. Rhonheimer should have known better, as tiresome as it is. But even this material has its moments, again built up to Smulders' talent as an actress. She really helps to make her cries funny, for better or worse.

I can't totally call this a great episode, but "Unfinished" makes me happy for Ted's character, and the show's future. The GNB building seems to be the thing he needs to go forward with his life, and let's hope it works.

Tuesday, June 9, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "Cleaning House"

Cleaning House (6x02)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Stephen Lloyd

One Paragraph Synopsis: Barney ropes the gang into helping him pack for Loretta, when he and James reminisce over their childhood. In actuality, their mother lied frequently to the both of them, but Barney's naivety allowed him to believe everything, right down to Bob Barker being his father. This is about to change when they find an undelivered letter to Sam Gibbs from Loretta, which contains a picture of the boys, stating that this is his son. They find where Mr. Gibbs lives in hopes of tying up loose ends, as James finally meets his father. Barney, still as clueless as ever though, believes Sam Gibbs to be his father, as he joins along in their catching up, until he comes to Loretta later. He doesn't find out who his father is today, but Barney doesn't need to- he has a pretty fine mother already.

Okay, is Barney's mugging racist? All signs point to me, being a white person, not being the right person to judge this at all, but for my view, this is similar to Steve Martin's opening bits in The Jerk. There isn't enough actual blackface to knock the material down,

Plus, like Marshall noted, Barney kind of just needed the afternoon. If he seriously thinks that Sam could have been his father, shit, let him live in his delusion for a little. It's also worth noting that the most problematic moment might be the robot voice spoof at the end, which besides that, goes on for too long.

It's a touchy subject, but the episode is tight, which is why I might give it more of a pass than usual. The plot is written quite well, Lloyd at his best as he sticks to the Stinsons' emotional cores. Not just Barney, either- it shows how strong Loretta and James are as characters that they're given plenty to handle themselves, and make it all work.

James works well as the gay, black, more in-control Barney. He's a little neurotic and cocky himself, but James is calmer and cooler usually. Getting the chance to meet his father is a good character move, allowing him some necessary closure. While the reveal of his father isn't as big of a deal to the audience as meeting Barney's would be, it's still a touching moment when James and Sam light up as the realization hits.

But the hit Barney has when he realizes that Sam isn't his father is definitely palpable. He's ready to admit that Bob Barker isn't his father, but life isn't ready to work out that way for him, which must hurt. And that's where he snaps, allowing himself a day to be black. Problematic as this might be, it gives Barney the chance to heal his wound briefly before it all comes out.

And it results in a great moment from Barney and Loretta, who herself is a good character. She still lives with some of her past lies, but is doing everything in her power to allow her sons the happiness they deserve, even if it's years removed.

Loretta lied to Barney and James to ensure that they kept their innocence, even when she wasn't the most innocent person around. There are cases where lying to your children is wrong, but usually her intentions were good, which is what Barney admires now. True, hiding her children from their fathers was not a great thing to do, but all that needs to be said is done when Barney dodges Loretta's reveal- Barney loves and admires her enough to keep the lie going, at least for now. More power to him.

If there's one problem with the episode, the aforementioned iffy taste in judgment aside, it's that there isn't a whole lot for the other characters to do. Ted and Robin have a cute little subplot in which she attempts to hook him up with a coworker, but it goes nowhere and lands towards a slightly offensive jab at her appearance, which hurts it a little more. Which is at least more than Lily and Marshall get, who are only offered a good line or two on the side.

That said, this is still a strong outing, one that's beneficial towards Barney's character, and hopefully telling that this is going to be a great season. Keep it up!

Sunday, June 7, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "Big Days"

Big Days (6x01)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Carter Bays & Craig Thomas

One Paragraph Synopsis: Ted and Marshall, years down the road, reflect on how crazy their life has been, as they go back to a time shortly after the season finale. Marshall and Lily are still trying to have a baby, but Lily's momentum is killed when she discovers that Marshall has confided in his father about the big news. She feels that he tells Marvin too much and that he is also too impulsive, which Marshall resents until his father butts in a little more than he should, thus making Marshall agree with Lily, as he promises to cut back on the information he shares. Also that night, Ted has his eyes on a girl, who meets up with his ex Cindy. It turns out that Cindy had came out in between their time together, a decision she thanks Ted for (but not in that way). And Robin is about to get out of her post-breakup funk just when Barney needs some motivation.

New season, new beginnings, new promises. And this is looking to be a nice year, based on the quality of this episode.

HIMYM is often at its best when the show focuses on each of the gang together, and "Big Days" is no exception. Bays and Thomas still understand their characters, and are not only finding a way to keep their developments exciting this late in the game, but they have also found a way to bring most of the core storyarcs of the season up front.

The lukewarm reception to the fifth season was not lost on the show's creators, who instantly agreed and decided to use the next season to rectify as many of those problems as possible. The ongoing character arcs that made the show as fun and essential to previously watch are brought back, as we'll see in the episodes to come.

Just as the previous season wasn't forgotten. Lily and Marshall's decision to have children is the main plot of the episode, as the stress behind the effort is felt. They haven't been trying for too long, but the fear that this may not happen is there, as they both compensate in different ways. Marshall relies on the guidance of others, most of all his father, during tough times, while Lily tends to latch onto her biggest pet peeves, such as Marshall's method of handling stress.

The Eriksens haven't shown up in a while, but they haven't been forgotten either, which makes Marvin's presence in the episode fit in. Marshall's dedication to his family has been well-documented, as Marvin is particularly a big voice of confidence to him, which explains why his father is the first person Marshall runs to with news such as his and Lily's hopes to be expecting. Marshall just wants his dad's advice and inclusion, which isn't really a bad thing.

It's a little more complicated when you consider how impulsive Marvin can be, though. He means well, but the Eriksens have a history of sticking their noses where they don't belong. That is partly why Lily fell for and married Marshall, since she's a Nosy Nelly herself, but based on his calls, Marvin can be a bit too much. The come around to this revelation from Marshall works, but Marvin isn't totally shut out either, thankfully. Frankly, it's just nice to see some of Marshall's family again, and the plot is rounded well and makes sense for the characters.

Ted's story is just as important, as evident by the opening tag. While we don't find out whose wedding he is the best man for, it seems like he really has changed a little by that time. This season is meant to show how he gets there, and his run-in with Cindy might show us exactly.

Like how I mentioned above, I like how Cindy's coming out isn't a result of a bad experience with Ted, but a culmination of her own life. This fits her place now, and as it's shown, she's found her happy ending. Sometimes life works like that- something you don't expect comes and it all fits in. And just as I enjoy seeing any of the Eriksens again, I'll never turn down a chance to see Rachel Bilson. Especially when she's seeing kissing another woman.

But to return to Ted, this is a good way to get his arc rolling, as he is seen pining for a woman he can't have with no insight as to how he should get to her. It seems typical, but the reminder of Cindy's roommate makes it seem like this could mean more, only for it to end so abruptly. Which is also true to life- even the littlest things can add up.

Ted still isn't ready to find the one and start the ending phase of his life. He thinks he is, but he's still stuck in his old ways for right now. He needs to grow a little first, find out what he needs to do with his life, and go for it before he does. Which it's all up for him to do.

Barney and Robin's material isn't as big as the other three, but they have their own matters to deal with. Barney's simple whining about the end of the sundress season is rightfully silly, and handled well for the character, but there's a taste of what's to come for his character in between- Barney is still hoping to find his father, Bob Barker or not. He appreciates Marshall and Marvin's relationship, wanting that for himself, but it just isn't possible yet. This should lead to some great growing for the character, and give him more to do than try to find a girl in a sundress to screw.

Robin, meanwhile, needed to sundress up to give herself a refresher. Leaving Don and moving back in with Ted wasn't great for her esteem, as evident by her... existence. While I do think the episode becomes a little too mean to Robin in the episode, her scenes make for some of the best and weakest material as such. It would have been a little nicer if the episode was nicer to her, but damn if seeing Robin in a garbage heep cry out that she's ready for sex isn't gold. This is shattered expectations at its best- when we expect the best, the worst is a million times better to see on screen. Her return to glam, however, shows that she's not out yet, and that this will hopefully be her year.

And while you're at it, keep a look at Barney's reaction to Robin's sundress. Does this mean that there is more for the two to deal with together? I dunno, but I'm happy with "Big Days". It promises a lot, and has so far delivered on much of it. Let's hope the season doesn't disappoint.

Tuesday, June 2, 2015

How I Met Your Mother Review- "The Wedding Bride"/"Doppelgangers"

The Wedding Bride (5x23)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Stephen Lloyd

One Paragraph Synopsis: Ted's trying his hardest to find his new girl Royce's (Judy Greer) baggage. The thing is, he's doing this while keeping his own baggage tightly lipped- he's still not talking about how Stella left him at the altar. At least, Ted didn't plan to until he and Royce go see the hot new romantic comedy, The Wedding Bride, written by Tony himself. The movie is a inaccurate retelling of the Stella affair, treating "Jed Mosley" like a complete jackass, as it shows Ted's side to be unbalanced. Ted hurts until he decides that it's for the best to tell Royce the truth, that he was left at the altar and it still hurts, especially when this movie is around to remind him of it. It doesn't matter though, since we don't see Royce after this episode.

Doppelgangers (5x24)

Directed by Pam Fryman
Written by Carter Bays & Craig Thomas

One Paragraph Synopsis: The quest to find Barney's doppelganger is over, when Marshall and Lily find a cab driver who looks just like him. This means that Lily is ready to keep her end of the bargain with Marshall and have a kid, until it turns out that the cab driver is actually a scheme of Barney's. They push their baby-making plans back until Lily finds a hot dog vendor that she swears is Barney's doppelganger, which Marshall doesn't even try to fight. But that isn't all- Robin was offered a anchor position in Chicago, which she almost takes, before realizing how much she loves Don, and is willing to give it up for him. Except, Don takes the offer himself, and the two break up instantly.

The fifth season was a roller coaster of quality, containing the show at its best and its worst, often at only an episode apart, and sometimes even in the same episode. These last two episodes maintain a good thing, but they're pretty different when you get down to it.

Most series usually start to lose their touch when they hit 100 episodes. There are plenty of exceptions to the rule, but it's around this point that most of the best possible stories have been exercised and character and plot beats are starting to increasingly be repeated. There's often a sense of familiarity that becomes involved with this- after a few years, showrunners are able to figure out virtually everything that fans like about their series, and are willing to burn them into the ground for the sake of keeping the cash flow coming.

I've mentioned before that at this point, Bays and Thomas knew that HIMYM was going to run for a while, and were willing to stall for a while to keep the good times coming. That sense of complacency hit the season pretty hard, as noticed when watching it as a whole. On a case by case basis, there doesn't seem to be too much of a decline in quality, at least if you don't hit the weakest episodes. But together, the lack of focus and general coasting nature is obvious, with a negative effect on the show.

I'm going over season 5 as a whole now, as this is the best time too. But I should probably get to the episodes in question first.

"The Wedding Bride" is a pretty funny episode, but I'm not sure if it was able to justify the full half hour without a side plot. The main theme of accepting and working on baggage is a strong one, but the Wedding Bride material, as funny as it is, runs a little thin at the end of the day.

It works as a reminder of Ted's grief from the Stella ordeal, though, just as it works as a parody of romantic comedies, even HIMYM itself. Chris Katan in particular is great as Jed Mosley, bringing some of Ted's general douchiness to screen as authentically as possible. Also note that Malin Akerman is here as Stella in a bit of synergy, as she stared in Radnor's directoral debut, which was so unremarkable that I forgot its name.

While I like this, I'm less enthused about seeing the gang be little more than spectators for Ted's issues, even as they have notable highlights- Barney is kissing awesome in particular. Lloyd is a good writer, and can do great stuff for the characters, but failed to dig further on the gang's baggage beyond an unremarkable endeavor into Marshall's kindness, which doesn't get resolved. Still, what works works well, as I find enough good in the episode to recommend.

"Doppelgangers", meanwhile, is a strong endeavor, ending the fifth season well, even if it isn't a five-star effort. Each of the characters have something important to deal with here, and it does help to lead into a (hopefully) promising sixth season.

Marshall and Lily's discussion on whether or not they're ready for children is answered throughout, based on the quest for the last doppelganger, And the results are telling to their current position. Marshall instantly sees the cab driver as a double of Barney, and while Lily is initially ready to side with him, she soon changes her mind even before learning that it was a double. But when she sees the random vendor, reality doesn't matter. The timing and circumstance is right- Lily is ready to have kids. And Marshall doesn't want to wait, either.

Robin's change is equally big- she's given the chance to pursue her dreams, but at the risk of losing her love in the process. The Robin of season 2 may or may not have made the same decision, but the Robin of season 5 seems happy with her call.

At least until she discovers that Don takes that offer, which is a huge blow. Robin's pride is still valid, and she's too strong to stay with someone who spit on her dreams like this. It's what keeps Robin going, and what will help her in the long run.

Barney's doppelganger attempt is sweet and welcome, as it shows how he really has grown over the years. Before, he never would have pushed for his friends to advance their life as much as he is,but this shows how there really is growth to the character. And we also see his grief when he discovers how Robin might leave. This is about more than just a friend moving away- he still really seems to like Robin, to the point that Barney would fight for her.

And Ted. Crazy, blond Ted. Not only is his bleached hair subplot funny, it prevents him from screwing things up by getting back with Robin. But maybe there's more to them, as well. It also shows how he has grown himself, as otherwise Ted might have taken that offer up, but seeing how Robin has changed over the years gives him an idea that it isn't for the best.

These are solid episodes, but my reservations about the fifth season remains. The thing is, the show still has the ability to be at the top of its game, which is why I still enjoy coming back to write up about it, even if it isn't as consistent as it was last season. I give season 5 a B-, the lowest score since the first season, but still respectful enough. Can season 6 bring things forward, though? Let's hope.